Post reply
Original Message:
Re: Manhattan Club Lawsuit (by Dennis C.):
Here is what ChatGpt says: The Manhattan Club (TMC) today is an independently operating, owner‑controlled timeshare association with a long history of legal and regulatory trouble, partial Bluegreen involvement in its governance, and ongoing disputes over inventory, reservations, and ownership transfers. It is not an HGV property, but Bluegreen has held board seats and acquired unsold developer inventory, which is why it sometimes appears connected.
Below is a full, evidence‑based deep dive using the most recent court and regulatory records.
---
🧱 What The Manhattan Club is
TMC is a timeshare property at 200 West 56th Street, New York City, structured as a cooperative-style timeshare association. The building is owned by The Manhattan Club Timeshare Association, Inc. New York Sta...
---
🕰️ Historical background: Fraud findings and state intervention
TMC became one of the most notorious timeshare cases in New York due to years of owner complaints about:
• Impossible reservations despite high fees • Inventory being rented to the public instead of owners • Misleading sales practices
In 2014, the New York Attorney General ordered TMC to stop selling timeshares due to alleged fraud. In 2017, the original developers (the Eichner family and related entities) entered an Assurance of Discontinuance, admitting deceptive practices and agreeing to:
• Pay $6.5 million in restitution • Sell their interest in TMC by 2021 • Be barred for life from the timeshare industry timesharelaw...
---
🔵 Bluegreen’s role: Limited but real
Bluegreen Vacations is not the owner of The Manhattan Club. However, Bluegreen did acquire the unsold developer inventory from the Eichner group in June 2018 and subsequently occupied four of seven seats on TMC’s board of directors. timesharelaw...
This is the only formal connection.
Important nuance: Bluegreen’s involvement came from acquiring the developer’s remaining interests—not from acquiring the building or the association. TMC remained structurally independent.
---
⚖️ Recent litigation (2020–2025): Owners vs. TMC & Bluegreen
A major lawsuit (Acklin v. Eichner / Bluegreen, filed 2020) alleged:
• RICO violations • Fraud • Breach of fiduciary duty • Tortious interference • Securities violations
Owners claimed they were sold worthless timeshares, charged exorbitant fees, and denied reservations. In February 2024, the federal judge dismissed the RICO claims with prejudice and declined jurisdiction over the state claims. Justia Law In November 2024, the court denied owners’ attempt to reopen the case. timesharelaw...
Owners may still pursue state‑level claims, but the federal case is closed.
---
🧩 Current operational issues (2024–2026)
Recent complaints and court filings show:
• Ongoing disputes over fraudulent or improper deed transfers (e.g., 2024–2025 Madeo case) New York Sta... • Long waitlists for deed‑back programs • Difficulty obtaining reservation availability • Maintenance fees that have risen significantly over time • Owners reporting inability to exit contracts (BBB complaints, 2025) Better Busin...
These issues are consistent with the property’s long‑standing operational problems.
---
🧭 Where things stand today (2026)
The Manhattan Club is:
• Not owned by HGV • Not owned by Bluegreen • Still controlled by its Timeshare Association • Still dealing with legal, operational, and owner‑relations challenges • Partially influenced by Bluegreen through past board seats and inventory ownership (though the extent of current board representation is not fully documented in 2026