The Harborside Inn

My friend and I recently spent three nights as renters in the Harborside Inn. Having never been to Martha's Vineyard before, I guess I was expecting a relaxing time in a quaint location. I was not prepared for the onslaught of overpriced designer shops and wall-to-wall people. Not my cup of tea!

As far as the Inn itself, it was pleasant enough, but frankly, not worth the price. As a renter, there were very few amenities, not even a coffeemaker in the room. This is standard fare for hotel rooms. The staff did put out pots of coffee around 7:00AM, but I am an early riser and love to sip morning coffee on the balcony before getting dressed, so I paid a high price to have less than I have at home.

These are not true condos. There is a communal kitchen for owners only. I can only imagine that it is an inconvenience for owners, and an expensive proposition for renters, being left in the cold to pay the ridiculously high prices of the local restaurants.

We had a pleasant, but not fantastic view of the harbor. Some of the units face out on South Water Street, which would, in my view, be unacceptable for the price. The hot tub was not available when we were there. The pool is rather small and overrun with kids. (I don't dislike kids, but my own are grown, and we have no grandchildren, so I am in a unique time of life...) Once again, big bucks for less than we have at home.

I "dinged" them on sleep comfort because the neighbor's air conditioner was loud and kept me awake at night, in spite of having the windows closed. The bed was amazingly comfortable, however, and the unit was kept immaculately clean.

The staff comes highly recommended. They were friendly, accommodating and helpful.

The people we met, mostly owners, were, for the most part, friendly. Many have been coming to the Harborside for years and love it. There were a couple of family reunions taking place when we were there.

All in all, not a bad experience, but not worth the money. I doubt if I'll be back.

A great deal in the heart of Edgartown. Wonderful staff, very clean, comfy beds. Sit on the outdoor deck in a rocking chair or at a table overlooking the harbor for breakfast. Use the outdoor grills or sit by the fire-pit and cook free s'mores. Very friendly guests who come here year after year. Heated pool, not crowded in June. Walk to Edgartown lighthouse and the beach, or rent a bike across the street and take the Chappy ferry around the corner. Rooms recently renovated.